Rethinking Free Markets, Free Trade & Growth

Wednesday, January 7, 2015 - 6:45pm
Betsy Bowman

As we contemplate the possible passage of theTrans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), we might reconsider the ideas of free trade and free markets and where these ideas came from. We should also take another look at the idea of growth, indeed endless growth. These are the issues Betsy Bowman will examine in a talk sponsored by the Center for Global Justice

Free trade, free markets and growth are repeated like a mantra — a bit of catechism that we all know by heart and that we all think to be beneficial goals in and of themselves. However, Adam Smith, writing before the French Revolution, and economic thinkers from the Middle Ages through the Modern period, all argued for free markets and free trade that were free not from government regulation but that were free from inherited privileges, monopolies and what economists call “economic rent” — unearned income. Neo classical economists such as Adam Smith did not argue for free markets where the strongest wins as seems to be the current view. He argued for markets and trade free from God-given privileges, rights and monopolies of the monarchy, aristocracy and the Church who all unfairly benefited from God- iven, unearned, structural, systemic advantages. We also know that today’s “wealthy” countries became wealthy not through free trade, but through protected trade and high tariffs, not to mention colonial rule. So let’s stop kidding ourselves that free trade is anything but big businesses pushing the smaller ones into bankruptcy.

Growth has been trumpeted as the great panacea — a solution for poverty and underdevelopment. We imagine that the 6% growth of those heady post WWII years is normal. Anything less than 5% per year growth is viewed as anemic. But Thomas Piketty shows in his widely aclaimed book Capital in the Twenty-First Century that growth has averaged only 1.5% over the last two centuries. The abnormally high growth of the post WWII period was abnormal, and it was due to the destruction of most of the world’s productive capacity i.e. all the factories of Europe and Japan. And this abnormally high growth only occurred in the US which exited WWII with its industrial base intact. The norm for normal growth is actually very low growth or stagnation as Marxist economists have pointed out for decades. But no one wants to believe that the natural rhythm of capitalism is stagnation instead of booming growth that lets the good times roll. Just 1.5%. Setting a realistic goal such as 1.5% growth could be enormously beneficial and helpful in reaching the real goal which is not profit regardless of all else and at any cost but instead the real goal is reducing carbon emissions and satisfying the needs of the world’s population.

UPCOMING TOURS

January 26, 2025 to February 4, 2025
Join us in an exciting visit to Cuba--a country committed to building socialism. We will learn about Cuba’s stunning accomplishments such as free health care and education, its collective production in agricultural and urban cooperatives, We will dialogue with leading thinkers about their visions... Read more
November 25, 2024 to November 29, 2024

We will depart from San Miguel early in the morning for an about two and a half hour drive to Morelia, known as the pink city, because the pink limestone used to build all of the historical mansions and churches. There we will spend one night, and almost two full days.

Upcoming Special Events

October 8, 2024 to October 12, 2024

As a part of the Global Action for Palestine, we invite you to VIVE PALESTINA 2024, a series of cultural events taking place in San Miguel de Allende. The event has its origins in a discussion on Palestine hosted by the Center for Global Justice some months ago. After that there was a followup meeting and a group of people decided to form... Read more

Upcoming Forums & Films

Monday, October 14, 2024 - 1:00pm
CST
Débora Poo
Location:
Hotel Quinta Loreto Community Room

The Palestinian people’s struggle for freedom, justice and equality needs your support. We will share information about the the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement that works to end international support for Israel's oppression of Palestinians and to pressure... Read more